Arbitrary detention has become a prominent feature of the geopolitical landscape, presenting a growing risk for businesses of any sector. Escalating geopolitical and diplomatic tensions between states, regional conflicts in key regions like the Middle East, and domestic insecurity will continue to drive detention threats for commercial personnel globally over the coming years.

The changing face of hostage diplomacy

“Hostage diplomacy”, when states demand economic or political concessions from foreign governments after detaining one of their nationals, has become a growing feature of the modern geopolitical environment. There are several reasons for this. Deepening diplomatic divisions, the fracturing of international consensus and a growing number of successful attempts to extract concessions from detainees’ home governments have all emboldened isolated states to escalate their use of this tactic.

Various Western governments have taken new measures to attempt to mitigate this threat to their citizens. In September 2025, the US established a new designation and policy framework, which allows states to be classified as State Sponsors of Unlawful Detention, in part to deter states from targeting American nationals. In July 2026, the UK government announced the first dedicated Envoy for Complex Consular Detentions to aid the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) amid the growing risk of arbitrary detentions for British nationals abroad. While similar measures are expected to be gradually implemented by other Western states in the coming years, they will have a limited actual mitigative impact on the detention threat posed by perpetrating states.

Judicial processes typically lack transparency

Hostage diplomacy as a tactic has been adopted historically by countries with strained or severed diplomatic relations with US and Western allies, such as Iran, Russia, Afghanistan and Venezuela. The tactic often sees a marked escalation where hostilities between both sides intensify. For example, in the immediate lead-up to the war between Iran, the US and Israel, Control Risks reported an increase in hostage diplomacy incidents in Iran targeting foreign nationals. However, in other cases, perpetrating governments may simply change their targets. In the aftermath of US action in Venezuela in January 2026, the regime shifted its targeting away from foreign nationals to purely local nationals, likely in a bid to reduce diplomatic pressure as the Rodriguez administration attempted to stabilise its rule.

The chief concern for employers is that hostage diplomacy incidents can impact both politically and economically sensitive sectors, and businesses whose activities have no clear ties to national security, economic or geopolitical concerns. Hostile governments will typically target individuals based on their nationality and perceived value, as a bargaining chip with their home government. Even victims with no family ties to a Western state may be targeted because they work for, or are associated with, an institution or organisation headquartered in that country. Judicial processes lack transparency, combined with limited access to consular backing or legal advice, which means that cases can last for extremely long periods. Of the detentions Control Risks recorded between January 2020 and June 2026, 30% lasted more than a month, and 11% for over a year. Many others have dragged on for years with no known outcome. Businesses will therefore not only face increasing challenges around the safety of their travelling staff, but also the risk of being entangled in years-long incidents with little recourse to bring about a resolution.

Arbitrary detention and assertive states

Detention threats do not solely extend to hostage diplomacy incidents. States, including those which have not historically relied on systematic political detentions, are increasingly resorting to the tactic domestically to mitigate perceived internal threats. Authorities are more likely to perpetrate arbitrary detentions of both domestic and foreign nationals, including those working for businesses stationed in-country, often under charges of espionage or anti-government activity.

In many states where arbitrary detention is a more established practice, increases in incidents are often the result of governments attempting to respond to perceived challenges to their own authority. In some countries in North Africa, Latin America, Central Asia and Eastern Europe, detention rates spike in response to periods of political upheaval, often during major election cycles. Elsewhere, for example in Syria or the Sahel states, governments with fractured territorial control will often use detention to limit the perceived threat from domestic (or foreign) opponents within their own strongholds.

Escalations in detentions may also be the result of growing tensions with regional neighbours. For example, in the Democratic Republic of Congo, authorities have become increasingly assertive in response to perceived hostile activity by neighbouring Rwanda, chiefly over their purported support of the M23 rebel group. This has included instances of the government detaining commercial employees of Rwandan origin, or those who hold perceived personal or commercial ties with Kigali. The threat is also not necessarily tied to specific employees: Control Risks has recorded cases where the detaining authority failed to locate the individual they were initially pursuing, only to detain an unrelated employee of the same company instead.

An increasingly prevalent risk to businesses will stem from detentions which emerge from business disputes or commercial issues, where aggrieved parties leverage connections with government figures to coerce target businesses into compliance. These detentions are a growing concern in markets where regulatory or contractual risks are comparatively higher and the overlap between government and commercial interests are more pronounced. These incidents can also escalate beyond the initial commercial dispute, often where authorities identify a political or financial motive to harden their stance or opportunistically exploit the detention for wider leverage with the victim’s home government. Such escalations can markedly extend the detainee’s duration in captivity, and complicate efforts to extract affected businesses’ assets or personnel from an ongoing incident.

Governments are increasingly citing visa violations or the publication of posts or recordings deemed to undermine national security to justify detentions. Travellers are subject to significantly more scrutiny than before, both at customs points and during their time in-country. Businesses are increasingly forced to consider dynamic risks stemming from local law, customs and regulatory requirements more closely, including for business travel that may have otherwise been routine. While organisations often have comparatively more recourse in these cases to leverage diplomatic or legal support, detentions of staff will nonetheless have significant impacts, whether through operational disruption, increased government scrutiny or the erosion of employee morale.

A complex threat environment 

Shifting geopolitical dynamics and escalating regional and domestic insecurities will continue to drive the complex detention threat environment for businesses and personnel globally over the coming years.

  • Hostage diplomacy will persist as a strategic tool leveraged by geopolitically isolated states, with detention activity fluctuating and reacting to wider diplomatic and geopolitical developments.
  • Tactics of states attempting to maintain stability amid both internal and external destabilising factors will result in heightened detention risks to both foreign and local personnel, given heightened isolationist tendencies and suspicion of oppositional and foreign interests.
  • Non-state armed groups attempting to maintain de facto authority over territories and economic assets will continue to drive the detention threat during protracted civil conflicts and divided states.

Outlook

Increasingly, organisations and commercial entities will face detention risks, both to their travelling personnel and their people on the ground in-country. Worsening geopolitical faultlines, domestic tensions and states’ increasing willingness to elevate independent control over international commerce will exacerbate the risks over the coming year. Maintaining continued awareness of detention trends and related sensitivities will continue to be critical for international organisations.

Control Risks maintains significant experience in supporting clients assessing detention risks to their personnel. Our team of expert multilingual analysts routinely carry out analysis on detention risks, leveraging combined knowledge gained from Control Risks Response’s more than 50 years of case experience, as well as our proprietary database of kidnap, extortion and arbitrary detention incidents. This, in addition to Control Risks Response’s in-house methodology on detention risks, grants the team unique insights into the shifting landscape of hostage diplomacy and arbitrary detention, and its trajectory over the coming years.

Our team can be reached at [email protected].

Get in touch

Can our experts help you?